Every NBA season, the debate over the Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) is one of the most hotly contested topics. Defense, often an underappreciated aspect of the game, is critical to a team’s success, and this year, as with every year, certain players have risen above the rest with their ability to impact games at the defensive end of the floor. But how do we evaluate the best defender in the league? Is it just about block shots, steals, or does it also factor in overall impact, versatility, and the ability to shut down elite opponents? Who truly deserves the title of the NBA’s Defensive Player of the Year?
In this article, we’ll dive into how to evaluate the top defensive players of the season, considering multiple factors that go beyond traditional statistics, and examine who has truly earned the title of defensive superstar.
1. The Criteria for Evaluating Defensive Players
A. Traditional Defensive Statistics
While the modern game emphasizes advanced metrics and more holistic evaluations, traditional defensive statistics still hold significant weight in evaluating a player’s defensive prowess. Some of the most common and valued stats are:
- Blocks: The ability to defend the rim and swat away shots is often associated with a dominant defensive presence. Players who average a high number of blocks can change the game’s flow by deterring opposing players from driving to the basket.
- Steals: Players who rack up steals have the ability to disrupt offensive flow, create fast-break opportunities, and serve as ball hawks on the perimeter. Steals often highlight a player’s anticipation and ability to read the game.
- Defensive Rebounds: While often associated with offense, securing defensive rebounds is also a key indicator of a player’s defensive awareness and ability to finish possessions. Players who excel in this area help their teams limit second-chance opportunities.
- Defensive Rating: This traditional metric evaluates a player’s efficiency in preventing points per 100 possessions while on the court. It’s a solid measure of a player’s individual contribution to the team’s defensive success.
B. Advanced Defensive Metrics
As the game of basketball evolves, so too has the way we evaluate defensive performance. Advanced metrics allow for a deeper understanding of a player’s impact on the defensive end, beyond the basic stats. These metrics include:
- Defensive Box Plus-Minus (DBPM): This is an advanced stat that measures a player’s impact on defense per 100 possessions, factoring in their ability to influence shots, disrupt passes, and limit scoring opportunities.
- Defensive Win Shares (DWS): This stat attempts to quantify a player’s contribution to their team’s defensive success and translate it into wins. A high DWS indicates a player has a significant effect on their team’s ability to prevent scoring.
- Individual Defensive Impact: This metric involves a player’s ability to lock down specific offensive players or schemes. It considers whether a defender can force turnovers, make offensive players uncomfortable, and create difficult shots for their opponents.
- Rim Protection Metrics: Stats like block percentage, defensive field goal percentage at the rim, and contest percentage help identify players who are elite in protecting the paint.
C. On-Ball Defense and Versatility
One of the most difficult aspects to quantify in a player’s defense is their ability to shut down individual players, especially star opponents. On-ball defense, while difficult to capture in traditional statistics, often determines the difference between a good defender and an elite one. Some key elements of on-ball defense include:
- Defensive Stance and Footwork: A defender’s ability to maintain proper positioning, move laterally, and prevent their opponent from getting to their spot is crucial.
- Defensive Matchups: A player’s ability to guard the opposing team’s best player, often for extended periods, is a sign of true defensive greatness. One-on-one defense is key when assessing whether a player has what it takes to lock down the league’s top scorers.
- Defensive Versatility: A player’s ability to switch between guarding various positions—whether it’s chasing guards off screens or defending larger forwards and centers—adds an extra dimension to their defensive resume. Defenders who can excel in multiple roles often provide more value to their team.
2. The Leading Defensive Players of the 2024 Season
After setting the criteria for evaluating defensive players, let’s take a look at some of the most notable candidates for the 2024 Defensive Player of the Year award. These players have been recognized for their elite defense and ability to influence the game on that end of the floor.
A. Jaren Jackson Jr. (Memphis Grizzlies)
Strengths:
- Elite Rim Protection: Jackson Jr. is widely regarded as one of the best shot-blockers in the league. His timing and ability to contest shots around the rim have made him a key anchor for the Memphis Grizzlies’ defense.
- Defensive Impact: Jackson’s rim protection alone often forces opponents to change their shots or avoid attacking the paint altogether. His Defensive Rating and Block Percentage are among the best in the league.
- Versatility: Jackson has shown the ability to guard multiple positions, thanks to his length, mobility, and defensive IQ. Whether it’s blocking shots at the rim or switching onto smaller players, Jackson has become a defensive cornerstone for Memphis.
Weaknesses:
- Foul Trouble: While Jackson’s shot-blocking ability is impressive, he can sometimes be prone to foul trouble, which limits his ability to stay on the court in key moments. However, his rim protection is so impactful that he can afford to take a few fouls.
B. Bam Adebayo (Miami Heat)
Strengths:
- Defensive Versatility: Adebayo is one of the most versatile defenders in the NBA. He can guard multiple positions, including centers and guards, and excels in pick-and-roll defense, making him a valuable asset for the Miami Heat. His ability to switch seamlessly between different types of offensive players gives him an edge in a league that emphasizes positionless basketball.
- On-Ball Defense: Adebayo is known for his elite on-ball defense, particularly against opposing big men. His agility, footwork, and strength allow him to hold his own against larger players while also being able to move his feet to guard smaller players on the perimeter.
- Rim Protection: Although not as dominant in blocking shots as someone like Jackson, Adebayo’s ability to contest shots at the rim and his defensive positioning make him a key deterrent for opposing teams.
Weaknesses:
- Inconsistent Shot-Blocking: While Adebayo’s ability to guard multiple positions is a huge asset, his block numbers aren’t as high as some of the league’s other premier shot-blockers, limiting his presence in that area.
C. Giannis Antetokounmpo (Milwaukee Bucks)
Strengths:
- Elite Athleticism: Giannis is arguably the most physically gifted player in the NBA, and his combination of size, speed, and agility makes him a nightmare on defense. Whether he’s protecting the rim or switching onto guards, Giannis has the versatility to do it all.
- Defensive Playmaking: Giannis has the ability to disrupt passing lanes, and his length and anticipation allow him to collect steals and deflections that lead to fast-break opportunities.
- Defensive Presence: Giannis has long been a defensive anchor for the Bucks. His ability to alter shots, shut down driving lanes, and defend without fouling has helped make the Bucks one of the top defensive teams in the league.
Weaknesses:
- Consistency in One-on-One Matchups: While Giannis can guard a variety of positions, he sometimes struggles with elite shooters and quick guards, as his defense can become overly reliant on his athleticism rather than technique.
D. Evan Mobley (Cleveland Cavaliers)
Strengths:
- Exceptional Rim Protection: Mobley has quickly emerged as one of the top young defenders in the NBA. His ability to protect the rim is outstanding, and his length and timing make him a constant presence in the paint.
- Defensive Awareness: Mobley’s IQ on defense is remarkable. He has a great sense of when to help, when to rotate, and how to contest shots without fouling. His impact goes beyond the stats—his mere presence alters how teams approach offense.
- Versatility: Mobley has shown an ability to guard both big men and perimeter players, making him a key piece in the Cavaliers’ defense.
Weaknesses:
- Strength: While Mobley is a phenomenal shot blocker and defender, he still needs to add more strength to truly dominate in one-on-one matchups against stronger forwards and centers.
3. Who Is the True Defensive Superstar?
Based on the criteria we’ve discussed, the answer to who is the true defensive superstar of the season is subjective and can vary depending on what you value most in a defender.
- Jaren Jackson Jr. may be the front-runner for many due to his overwhelming rim protection and elite shot-blocking abilities.
- Bam Adebayo stands out for his unmatched versatility and his ability to guard nearly every position on the court.
- Giannis Antetokounmpo remains one of the most physically dominant defenders in the NBA, with a unique blend of athleticism, versatility, and defensive instincts.
- Evan Mobley, though younger, is already an elite shot-blocker and versatile defender, and his growth could make him a future perennial DPOY candidate.
Ultimately, the title of Defensive Player of the Year in 2024 will come down to individual preferences—whether you prioritize rim protection, versatility, or overall defensive impact. But one thing is certain: these players, along with others, have truly elevated the importance of defense in today’s NBA, and they all have a case to be considered the true defensive superstar.
Discussion about this post